ATO Decisions And Objections
Objecting To ATO Decisions
Preparing an objection to a tax, GST or penalty assessment or some other ATO decision is not easy.
The consequences of getting it wrong can severely compromise your legal position and might limit the arguments that are available to you.
Our tax lawyers have worked at the ATO where they determined tax objections. They know:
- Which arguments are more likely to be accepted and which are likely to fail
- The evidence required to satisfy the “burden of proof” that taxpayers face
- How to craft a persuasive and correct legal argument to maximise your chances of receiving the correct decision in relation to your tax dispute
For expert advice and assistance in dealing with your objection to an ATO decision, please contact us.
Disclaimer: The information on this page is not legal advice, is for general information purposes only, and is not specific to any person or situation. There are many factors that may affect your circumstances. You should seek professional advice from a suitably qualified and licensed advisor before making any decisions.
What Our Clients Say About Us on Google
Posted on Google sarath JayawardanaTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I engaged Mathews Tax Lawyers after finding them through a Google search, seeking advice on a company tax matter following initial contact with a local firm. From the outset, the experience was seamless and highly professional. I was able to speak directly with the principal lawyer, Mark Mathews, who took the time to understand my situation, explained the process clearly, and provided an indicative fee on the spot. His depth of knowledge and clarity gave me immediate confidence to proceed. After I provided a detailed summary of the facts and requested a formal quote and timelines, he responded promptly—on the same day—with a clear fixed fee and practical guidance. Importantly, he advised that additional steps (such as further reports or rulings) were unnecessary at this stage, which reinforced my trust in his integrity and expertise. He initially indicated that the written advice would be provided within five working days. In fact, I received a comprehensive, well-reasoned legal opinion within just three days. The analysis was thorough, precise, and directly addressed the key issue, giving me a high level of confidence in proceeding. I am extremely satisfied with the service and would have no hesitation in recommending Mathews Tax Lawyers to individuals or companies seeking expert, efficient, and commercially sound tax advice.Posted on Google nathan shawTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Mark was exceptional to deal with from start to finish. He was professional, efficient, and always quick to respond, which made the whole process feel easy and well managed. What really stood out was how clearly he explained everything along the way. He took the time to make sure I understood each step, and it was obvious he has a deep knowledge of what he does. I’d highly recommend Mark to anyone looking for someone reliable and easy to work with. Thanks again Mark, I really appreciate your help.Posted on Google Dan ScougallTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I own an accounting firm and recently had the pleasure of dealing with Mark on a client matter. I had been speaking with another legal practice who simply didn't do what they had promised and was referred to Mathews Tax Lawyers. Mark was very efficient and pleasant to deal with, as well as providing the exact information we required. Would highly recommend thank you for your help.Posted on Google Robert KTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. There has been two ocassions now that I've spoken to Mark to see what I should do about a situation, each time he's spent 15 minutes or so giving me a direction or whether he can help with things. I've never had a laywer before but Mark was just someone that just seems to legimately care about his clients instead of making a quick buck from them. It appears that I'm not the only person who has this view reading the past comments. There's certain things outside of Mark's control obviously but it feels good when you have someone who you feel is on your side.Posted on Google Fabian RupertiTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. After submitting a brief online enquiry, I promptly received a call from Mark, who was already well-informed about my specific situation. He took the time to explain everything clearly and thoroughly over the phone. Mark was incredibly friendly, never tried to upsell unnecessary services, and provided honest, helpful advice free of charge. I’m truly grateful for his support—thank you!Posted on Google Andrew WaltersTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. Review: Mathews Tax Lawyers Pty Ltd We were thoroughly impressed by the professionalism and clear communication from Mathews Tax Lawyers. Their legal advice was well-explained, practical, and gave us real confidence in navigating the ATO’s compliance requirements. Responsive, knowledgeable, and easy to deal with from start to finish. We would highly recommend their services. Connect4U AustraliaPosted on Google Anne GrantTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I selected Mark randomly from an internet search for tax advice and so was a little anxious. But I was very fortunate. I found Mark to be professional, but very approachable and kind. He quickly researched the matters I was concerned about, was knowledgeable and provided an immediate way forward. I can wholeheartedly recommend Mark to anyone looking for tax advice.Posted on Google George MTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I am happy to engage Mark’s services above numerous other Tax Lawyers, as he actually demonstrated to me that he was a man of integrity that is considerate of his client's needs. So many firms publicize that they provide a “free initial consultation” to help assess your needs and determine how they can best help you. Rather than assessing your needs, the majority of them spend that time simply telling you their service costings instead. Despite not advertising for a “free initial consultation”, when I rang Mark he was the only one who was attentive to the details I explained regarding my case and even highlighted issues that were in my interest to focus on cost effectively without giving formal legal advice. What a refreshing change to my experience with numerous other Lawyers! Mark is the kind of person that I am looking for. He showed a sincere interest in my case and was considerate enough to care about my wellbeing with genuine professional integrity, which I greatly appreciated. I highly recommend Mark’s services for you to navigate the complexities of the ATO maze with caring support.Posted on Google Alex Yan AuroraTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I would highly recommend Mark to others. Although our case did not align with their business focus, Mark still took the time to thoroughly explain things to us and provided valuable advice that was undoubtedly helpful. We truly appreciate his professionalism, expertise, and patience.Posted on Google Bernard PeelTrustindex verifies that the original source of the review is Google. I found Mark professional, well prepared and helpful. I have no hesitation recommending Mark. Bernard P
Frequently Asked Questions
You’re not the first person to wonder about these things. Most of our clients come to
us with similar worries.
What does a tax lawyer do that an accountant can’t?
Accountants focus on compliance and tax returns. A tax lawyer represents you legally — in audits, disputes, and litigation — and protects your rights when things go wrong.
When should I call Mathews Tax Lawyers?
As soon as you receive notice of an audit, penalty, or investigation. The earlier we act for you, the more options you may have.
Can you help if the ATO is already taking action?
Yes. Even if the review or audit process has started, we can still represent you and work towards the best outcome.
Do you work outside Brisbane?
Yes. We act for clients anywhere in Australia, with our headquarters in Brisbane and virtual offices in Sydney and Melbourne.
How do your fees work?
Costs depend on the complexity of your matter. We provide clear, upfront estimates before starting work, so you know what to expect. Where possible and depending on the scope of work, we provide fixed fees.